| Category | Assignment | Subject | Business management |
|---|---|---|---|
| University | Module Title | Globalisation and Corporate Governance |
Impact of Globalisation on Local Businesses: The Case of Uber Technologies Inc.
1.1 Analyze the effects of globalisation on organisations operating nationally using the PESTLE approach.
1.2 Evaluate the role of trading blocs such as the EU on organisations with global presence.
1.3 Explain the roles and responsibilities of international organisations for harmonising business practice globally
OTHM Level 7 – Globalisation and Corporate Governance – Task 1 (AC 1.1, 1.2, 1.3)
Globalisation is the increasing mutual dependence of the national economies because of the flow of goods, capital, technology, information and people. For businesses with only a national or city market it brings new competition, new customers and new rules. Uber Technologies Inc., which was established in San Francisco in 2009, is a clear example of both sides. It's introduced taxi services in the rest of the world with one smartphone system, and in the short-term it challenged to the established local players on the back of global venture capital. It was sanctioned, protested and came under the #DeleteUber campaign by 2017 and, in September, Transport for London (TfL) chose not to renew its London license due to a failure of corporate responsibility that could impact on public safety and security.
This report aims to (1) examine the impact of globalisation on local businesses with the example of Uber, (2) include an analysis of the impact of globalisation on the national economies applying the PESTLE framework, and (3) a review of the role of the European Union (EU) and international institutions. The analysis is based on the position in 2017 with subsequent developments mentioned, if applicable.
Uber is a platform company. Owns no vehicles, does not have most drivers on staff, instead matches riders and drivers via software, and charges a commission. This asset light model spreads trans-border at very low marginal costs and more users make the platform more valuable. The result for consumers has been reduced waiting time, cashless payment and sometimes lower fares. It has provided flexible access to the labour market for the drivers.
But it's a mixed story for local businesses. Traditional taxi companies are subject to licensing, vehicle and insurance requirements and in London, the “Knowledge” test that increase their expenses. Uber has tried to operate on the fringes of many of these regulations, which the incumbents said it was unfair competition. This exemplifies what calls the globalisation paradox: closely intertwined global markets and nationally established rules. Friedman says globalisation does equal the playing field while Stiglitz says the benefits are not equally shared. Uber has both sides of the argument: it has opened up new opportunities and taken away the value of local licences and existing drivers' livelihoods. Local companies have reacted by following suit with their own applications, pressuring government to be more stringent, and filing lawsuits.
Political.
Globalisation reduces the autonomy of governments in formulating policies, but states have not been able to give in. Cities in Europe, Asia and Africa have imposed a variety of licensing rules and bans on Uber's expansion, and the 2017 decision by a regulator is a sign of a new campaign of national control. Openness to foreign platforms varies widely between countries as governments have to balance the benefits to consumers with protection for existing workers and the protection of public safety against foreign platforms.
Economic.
Foreign capital and know-how are directed to the national markets through globalisation. The company's expansion was capitalized by a group of global investors who were willing to take big losses for market share and possess more pricing power than local companies. National economies create jobs, flexible income and consumer savings, but also expose themselves to risks: work insecurity for drivers, pressure on incumbent companies, fears of profits and tax shifting to other jurisdictions through international corporate setups.
Social.
Global brands can boom the consumption culture and the expectations from the consumers very rapidly – but the social reaction runs just as quickly. In January 2017, #DeleteUber was trending after Uber was seen to be supporting a taxi strike in New York, and a public post by a former engineer further hurt the brand's reputation due to a sexual discrimination incident. The social cost of flexible working is being highlighted in wider conversation about driver welfare and the gig economy.
Technological.
In the era of smartphones, GPS, mobile payments and data analytics it's possible to have cross-border platforms and users have instant access. The very same technology poses threats to privacy, surveillance and security. The governance challenge of digital globalisation has been highlighted by the impetus of Uber's secretive data breach in 2016 that impacted approximately 57 million users, which was reported in November 2017, and by the fact that Uber reportedly used software to evade regulators.
Legal.
The primary forum for addressing the issues of globalisation is the national court. In November 2017, drivers were found to be “workers” by an employment tribunal in the UK who were entitled to minimum wage and paid holiday. In December 2017, the Court of Justice of the European Union decided that Uber is a transport service and not simply a digital service, meaning that the member states may ask for licences. With divergent national rules, the cost and complexity of compliance are prohibitive for global companies.
Environmental.
Evidence is disputed. While it could be argued that cheaper on-demand rides would lead to a decrease in car ownership and an increase in vehicle use due to sharing, the critics would suggest that more people are using vehicles and, in turn, adding to congestion in city centres. The authorities thus have to balance the costs of emissions and congestion against convenience when assessing the degree to which their markets should be open to such services.
|
Factor |
Opportunity |
Threat |
|
Political |
Foreign investment, innovation |
Failure to exercise control; ban and protest. |
|
Economic |
Jobs, lower fares, flexible income |
Stress on incumbents; uncertainty of income; tax issues |
|
Social |
Convenience, wider access |
Welfare debate on gig-work; reputation damage. |
|
Technological |
Instant, low-cost cross-border service |
Data breaches, privacy and surveillance; |
|
Legal |
Clearer rules after test cases |
Fragmented, costly compliance |
|
Environmental |
Possible lower car ownership |
Added congestion and emissions |
4. The Role of the European Union
The EU is the most developed trading bloc. It features a single market where goods, services, capital and people move freely and where there is a common external tariff and competition rules. This means to the organisations with an international presence, they have access to approximately 500 million consumers under a common framework, lower the number of trade barriers, and greater legal certainty. Data protection is a good example of harmonisation – the General Data Protection Regulation (Regulation (EU) 2016/679), which is due to come into effect from May 2018, applies to any organisation that processes the personal information of individuals in the EU and can result in fines of up to 4% of global turnover or €20m. It is a big issue because of what Uber did on their breach in 2016.
Global companies also are affected by the EU. So the Court in Elite Taxi upheld Uber's argument that they are an information society service therefore subject to the freedom of services, and thus not subject to national licensing. It remains largely a member-state affair, so there is a lot of fragmentation and Uber was treated differently in different markets. Compliance is most expensive for smaller companies, but larger multinationals can lobby! Brexit, which began in March 2017 when Article 50 was invoked, brings uncertainty for businesses in the UK, which could lose access to the Single Market. Other regional groups, like those of ASEAN and NAFTA, provide comparable, but less deep integration.
Overall, the EU is a chance and a protection. Reduces barriers for companies to scale, but also provides EU and national regulators with power to safeguard local stakeholders – local businesses gain from common standards that foreign businesses need to adhere to.
5. The Role of International Institutions
Business practice is harmonised in various ways by international institutions.
World Trade Organisation (WTO). The WTO enforces trade agreements, resolves trade disagreements and encourages trade liberalisation. In the General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS), the application of principles of non-discrimination – namely most-favoured-nation and national treatment – only occurs in sectors where a commitment is made. It promotes an unobtrusive form of protectionism in the form of its rules, while the regulation of domestic taxi services is generally left to national governments.
International Monetary Fund (IMF) The IMF's functions include encouraging monetary cooperation and exchange-rate stability among members, and provides loans to members experiencing balance-of-payments problems, typically conditionally (IMF, 2011). Stability is crucial for trade and investment, but is also criticized for being predicated on the need for fast liberalization before firms are ready to compete with foreign companies.
World Bank. It funds development and infrastructure, which boosts the markets and institutions in which firms operate.
OECD and ILO. The OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and the Principles of Corporate Governance contain voluntary standards for responsible conduct and the standards of the International Labour Organization relate to the status and welfare of gig workers.
These bodies are in harmony by establishing common trade rules (WTO), stabilising financial conditions (IMF) and spreading common norms. Most, however, have little control over individual companies and critics allege that they are dominated by powerful states. Global harmonisation is partial, as such conflicts as Uber's were dealt with by national regulators and courts.
6. Conclusion
Uber is a testament to the fact that globalisation offers practical advantages for national economies, such as investment, innovation, lower fares and flexible working hours, but also provides a challenge for local businesses and regulators. The PESTLE analysis reveals that political, legal and social retaliation is possible in a flash for an overseas company that is perceived as not respecting local rules and responsibilities. EU and international institutions help to open markets and establish common standards while leaving a lot of regulation to national authorities. Technology, and service quality, should therefore be part of the local business profile, whilst companies operating on a global scale should adjust their governance to meet local demands. The precedent set by Uber's recent leadership shakeups and its reinstated licence to operate in London in 2018 highlights the need for corporate responsibility as a prerequisite for sustainable global growth.
Task 2: Presentation
2. Be able to critically discuss the socio-cultural, ethical and moral issues that affect global organisations.
2.1 Critically analyse various socio-cultural, ethical and moral factors that may affect global organisations.
2.2 Compare and contrast organisational approaches to ethically manage a globally diverse workforce.
2.3 Critically discuss the roles and responsibilities of global organisations to improve workforce welfare.
Slide 1
Slide 2
Slide 3
Slide 4
Slide 5
Slide 6
Slide 7
Consumer Protection and Online Trading: Uber in the United Kingdom
3. Be able to analyse the role of corporate governance in global organisations.
3.1 Justify the significance of responsible corporate governance in global organisations.
3.2 Critically analyse the regulatory requirements that shape corporate governance in global organisations.
3.3 Critically evaluate the impact of regulatory requirements on corporate stakeholders’ interests in a global organisation.
4. Be able to critically discuss International Consumer Protection laws.
4.1 Analyse the significance of national and international legal frameworks covering consumer protection laws.
4.2 Examine key international consumer protection laws that may affect the operations of a global organisation.
4.3 Evaluate the measures that exist in a global organisation to protect consumers’ interests.
5. Be able to critically analyse regulations related to online trading.
5.1 Analyse the significance of the UK legislations related to online trading.
5.2 Determine the actions that need to be taken by organisations to ensure they are adhering to the key online trading legislations.
OTHM Level 7 – Globalisation and Corporate Governance – Task 3 (AC 4.1, 4.2, 4.3, 5.1, 5.2)
1. Introduction
This report analyzes Uber Technologies Inc in United Kingdom (UK) with a specific emphasis on London. The UK is a good choice as it is a large European market for Uber, the decision of Transport for London (TfL) not to renew Uber's licence was made there in 2017 and there is a growing body of consumer and online trading law in the UK. The law is presented as it was in 2017 (when the UK was still an EU member state), and any changes after then are indicated at the end.
Consumer protection law is in place because consumers and businesses are not on equal footing. Firms have more information, standard terms which they assume customers read but don't negotiate and assume a subservient role. But online it's worse: the consumer has no chance to check the service before using it, it's based on the platform's own ratings and pricing, and it gives the platform personal, payment and location information. When it comes to ride-hailing, the risk is even greater, as it's not just money that's at stake, but the safety of the user. People are therefore well protected by strong consumer law, a level playing field for compliant competitors and trust in digital markets is maintained.
The national and international frameworks are important to a global organisation for another reason. International guidelines, like the United Nations Guidelines for Consumer Protection and the OECD recommendation on e-commerce, establish common guidelines which are implemented by national legislation. For a company such as Uber, it is a baseline standard that is consistent from one country to the next, but enforcement is slightly different and so are the details, so that's why Uber has been treated so differently between various jurisdictions.
Important here is online trading law, as Uber is 100% app based. All bookings are distance transactions, meaning that e-commerce, data protection and unfair practice rules apply from the point of signing up to the point of payment and even after that until the data is stored. Compliance is also a regulatory requirement: TfL's definition of ‘fit and proper' is used to determine a licence holder's right to trade and legal deficiencies can be a direct consequence of losing this right.
2. Summary of Consumer Protection Laws
2.1 International and EU frameworks
The United Nations Guidelines for Consumer Protection revised in 2015 delineate consumers' legitimate needs, including: safety, protection of economic interests, access to information, redress and privacy, and that governments have a role to play in legislating and businesses to play good practice (United Nations, 2016). The OECD Recommendation on Consumer Protection in E-commerce incorporates additional principles for e-commerce, including transparency and fairness of the business practices, provision of information, secure payment methods and access to dispute resolution (OECD, 2016). They are soft law, which means that they have an impact but do not have to be adhered to.
EU law was the binding international layer for the UK in 2017, including the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive 2005/29/EC (Unfair Contract Terms Directive 93/13/EEC), the Consumer Rights Directive 2011/83/EU, the E-Commerce Directive 2000/31/EC and the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) (Regulation (EU) 2016/679). In the UK, each has been enacted into law and they provided a broadly similar standard in EU markets, which gave Uber a common, broad benchmark. EU law, however, does not prevent transport companies from being subject to national transport licences, as demonstrated by the Court of Justice's ruling in Elite Taxi (2017).
2.2 UK consumer protection legislation
The primary legislation is the Consumer Rights Act 2015. Requires services to be provided with reasonable care and skill (s.49), as information provided before the contract is made (s.50), within a reasonable time (s.52) at a reasonable price, where there is no agreement thereto (s.51) and remedies for repeat performance or price reduction. Part 2 contains provisions that prevent unfair terms from being enforced against consumers (s.62) and that terms must be transparent and prominent (s.68). This has implications for Uber when it comes to cancellation fees, exclusions of liability, and the explanation of variable pricing.
Unfair commercial practices are banned by the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008, such practices include misleading actions, misleading omissions and aggressive practices. They are applicable to Uber's fare disclosure, and to any marketing statements pertaining to driver screening or safety.
Pre-contract information and right to cancel is required for distance contracts under the Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013. Passenger transport contracts are excluded to a large degree and Uber cannot rely on the Regulations as their primary source of duties, though to the extent that they are not excluded, legal advice should be obtained to ensure the Regulations apply.
Passengers are also covered by the sector rules. The operators, drivers and vehicles must be licensed under the Private Hire Vehicles (London) Act 1998, and TfL imposes conditions on record keeping, safety and reporting. Discrimination, including disabled passengers' access is forbidden by the Equality Act 2010.
3. Summary of Online Trading Laws (AC 5.1)
The Electronic Commerce (EC Directive) Regulations 2002 make it necessary for online traders to disclose their identity and contact information, mark commercial communications as distinguishable, acknowledge orders electronically and allow the user to correct inaccurate data entries. These are simple transparency obligations which need to be fulfilled in every Uber booking screen.
When it comes to data protection, a platform storing journey, location and payment information is the most challenging. The Data Protection Act 1998 was in force in 2017. The GDPR and Data Protection Act 2018 impose new obligations including the need to have a lawful basis for processing, security, transparency and notifying the regulator of serious breaches within 72 hours within the GDPR and fines of up to 4% of global annual turnover or €20 million (Regulation (EU) 2016/679) as of 25 May 2018. Rules on consent to electronic marketing are added under the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations 2003.
What makes this law so important is that it shifts the responsibility to the online trader, not the consumer. Uber's 2016 exposure of approximately 57 million users across the globe, announced just in November 2017, tells the tale of the price of failure. The UK regulator later charged Uber £385,000 for poor security measures. The case demonstrates how data failures result in financial penalties, regulatory attention, and reputational damage.
4. Measures Protecting Consumers at Uber (AC 4.3)
Uber has instituted several safeguards in its model. Riders get an initial fare estimate, driver's name, driver's photo, vehicle information and can track and share a trip in real time. There is no paper pay and receive, riders and drivers rate each other, there is assistance in the app and trips are covered by insurance. The features are traceability and information that a taxi that calls you on the street may not be able to match.
The weaknesses are severe, though. TfL found that Uber's methods of reporting serious criminal offences, how it was seeking medical certificates and criminal-record checks for drivers, and how its software was being used to circumvent regulators posed questions that the public's safety and security were under threat. The report of the software used, called Greyball, was a deliberate avoidance of enforcement (Isaac, 2017), and the timing of disclosure of the data breach hurt trust. Effective ratings and technology should not take the place of good vetting and dealing with regulators. Convenience protections and information protections were generally robust, while governance protections were generally weak, as growth outpaced compliance.
5. Protectionism and Retaliatory Tactics
Protectionist policies give existing businesses protection from new competitors. Licensing, in the context of services, can have a legitimate safety function, but can also be a way in which the incumbent can shape the rules in their favour, which is known as regulatory capture. London's licensed taxi industry has the exclusive right to call cab and have been the benefactors of stricter regulations on private hire, including the English-language test for drivers in 2016. Both a public-interest rationale and a competitive effect exists for these measures, which should be recognised. Critics also say that, “Uber took advantage of the lack of regulation and shifted the social costs to others.”
There have been a variety of counter-measures taken by business and consumer groups. In 2014, licensed taxi drivers protested in large numbers in London, and lobbied TfL and politicians. Other competitors were Rivals, which provide taxi booking through their app. The Aslam case was supported by trade unions, the GMB, which found that drivers were “workers”. Consumers did so via social media, primarily by creating the hashtag #DeleteUber, and hundreds of thousands who signed a petition against the licence decision. So public opinion was bipolar and legitimacy was not just about being legal.
6. Conclusions and Recommendations (AC 5.2)
The 2017 licensing decision demonstrates that the regulators will take action when a platform doesn't seem to be taking responsibility for consumer rights to fair terms, good information, safe service, data protection, or when it claims to do so. To meet this requirement, and to regain trust, Uber should do the following:
1. Strengthen compliance governance. Refresh the board level risk and compliance role, including a named lead for regulatory matters in the UK, and regular board level audits, in response to TfL's concerns about 'weak corporate responsibility'.
2. Raise safety standards. Collaborate with TfL for criminal-record and medical checks, and report serious offences against the police in a timely fashion, whilst publishing incident data transparently.
3. Enhance fairness and transparency. Make prices and variable prices visible when booking, ensure that terms are checked with Part 2 of the Consumer Rights Act and provide easy access to complaints and alternative dispute resolution procedures.
4. Embed data protection. Understand and apply privacy by design, designate a data protection officer, have a quick response plan for data breaches, and have proper consent for marketing – before GDPR comes into effect in 2018.
5. Satisfy online trading responsibilities. Enter necessary trader data, accept orders and correct errors in app and site.
6. Involve non-participants in the law. Be open and frank with TfL, taxi trade, unions and consumer groups, discuss driver welfare in the context of the Aslam ruling, do not engage in tactics like Greyballing, respond to protectionist proposals with evidence instead of regulatory arbitrage.
Table 1: Compliance action plan
|
Law or risk |
Key requirement |
Recommended Uber action |
|
Consumer Rights Act 2015 |
Care and skill; fair, transparent terms |
Terms of audit and audit fees explanation |
|
Unfair Trading Regulations 2008 |
No deceptive or predatory business tactics. |
Check safety and price claims with manufacturer or retailer. |
|
E-Commerce Regulations 2002 |
Order details; confirmation of the trade(s); order acknowledgement. |
Check app and website information |
|
GDPR / Data Protection Act 2018 |
Security; 72-hour breach notice |
Privacy by design; breach protocol |
|
PHV (London) Act 1998 |
Licensed operator conduct |
Cooperate with TfL; report offences |
|
Protectionism and retaliation |
Stakeholder legitimacy |
Ongoing dialogue and transparent lobbying |
Later developments. Following a shift in leadership and behaviour, TfL issued Uber a short-term London licence in June 2018 and the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008 have been superseded by the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024. If required, verify current legislation prior to submission.
UPTO55%
Avail The Benefit Today!
Fill Out the Order Form for Free Access
This is an OTHM Level 7 Entrepreneurship and Innovation Assignment, unit reference L/616/2730, Unit title: Globalisation and corporate governance sample. This sample is written with the intention of providing help to all students who are pursuing OTHM Level 7. This is to make sure that every student who is struggling with their OTHM Level 7 assignment gets a chance to make sure that they score good grades. As this sample will help them in understanding how they can do their assignment, as most of the students get confuse in whether to simply write answers to these questions or do we need to write them according to the given task. And if we need to write according to the given task, then which question should be in which task? In short, it's quite complicated. So, it's better that a professional who has been helping OTHM students for more than 8 years guides you through these assignments. Here at Workingment, we have professional writers who can provide OTHM assignment help and handle your assignment from start to end and make you completely stress-free. But we understand that many students also prefer doing their own assignment, so we help them by uploading such samples. This sample is written by one of our professionals only, so that you can go through this sample and understand how you need to write your assignment. You can go through this and understand the format of your assignment and its writing style, and make sure that you write an assignment that helps you pass your assignment. If you want to score well, then you simply need to contact us and be stress-free.
Get Your Free Academic Quote
No hidden fees · Instant response · 100% confidential
Let's Book Your Work with Our Expert and Get High-Quality Content
dfh