MSM7043 Professional Development, Practice and Performance Assessment Brief 2024-25 | CMU

0 – 49%

50 – 59%

60 – 69%

70+%

Critical

Rudimentary and

Some criticality is

Substantial

Excellent critical

Thinking and

superficial, little or

achieved, although

examples of the use

reflection skills are

reflection

no examples of

when analysis,

of critical reflection

demonstrated

40%

analysis, synthesis

synthesis and

are demonstrated,

through the

and evaluation are

evaluation are

what is considered is

application of

demonstrated. The

considered, they

considered well, but

analysis, synthesis

work is largely

tend to be used in a

analysis, synthesis

and evaluation in

descriptive and

basic and simplistic

and evaluation might

considering wide

lacks any criticality.

ways, and often

have been taken

ranging ideas and

state generalities.

further.

observations, and

connections with

other material on and

off topic are

considered.

Observation,

Simplistic

Adequate degree of

Elements of the

Sophisticated and

Insight, and

observation which

observation, some

reflection show

thoughtful

Evidence

provides little or no

insight and

sophisticated

observation, a high

40%

insight, analysis is

analysis, reflection

observation and

degree of insight and

largely descriptive

on outcomes

analysis, but this is

analysis throughout

rather than

considered but

inconsistently

the work. A wide

reflective. Limited

lacks depth.

applied throughout

range of evidence

or no evidence of

Satisfactory

the work. A good

provided and

engagement and

evidence of

range of evidence

reflected upon.

progress provided.

engagement and

provided and

progress provided.

reflected upon.

Language and

A poorly organised

The work has a

A well-structured

Excellent coherence

Structure

piece of work, with

sound structure

piece of work in

and progression,

20%

many significant

where ideas and

which the main ideas

ideas and

ideas missing.

observations follow

and observations are

observations are very

Vocabulary is weak,

a logical

well considered.

well structured.

and the work

progression.

The vocabulary used is

There is an excellent

contains numerous

Competent

very good, with

use of vocabulary,

grammatical errors.

vocabulary, with

relatively few

and there are no

Errors in

some 

grammatical errors.

(few) grammatical

referencing.

errors. Harvard

Harvard referencing

errors.

referencing

correctly followed.

Harvard referencing

followed with minor errors.

correctly followed.