12 Questions to Help You Make Sense of Cohort Study Checklist – Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP)

Published: 07 Aug, 2025
Category Assignment Subject Education
University - Module Title Cohort Study Checklist

(A) Are the results of the study valid?

Screening Questions

1. Did the study address a focused issue?

HINT: A question can be ‘focused’ In terms of

  • The population studied
  • The risk factors studied
  • The outcomes considered
  • Is it clear whether the study tried to detect a beneficial or harmful effect?

Yes, can’t tell no

2. Was the cohort recruited acceptably?

HINT: Look for selection bias, which might compromise the generalisability of the findings:

  • Was the cohort representative of a defined population?
  • Was there something special about the cohort?
  • Was everybody included who should have been included?

Yes, can’t tell No

Is it Worth Continuing?

Detailed Questions

3. Was the exposure accurately measured to minimise bias?

HINT: Look for measurement or classification bias:

  • Did they use subjective or objective measurements?
  • Do the measurements truly reflect what you want them to (have they been validated)
  • Were all the subjects classified into exposure groups using the same procedure

Yes, can’t tell  no

4. Was the outcome accurately measured to minimise bias?

HINT: Look for measurement or classification bias:

  • Did they use subjective or objective measurements?
  • Do the measures truly reflect what you want them to (have they been validated)?
  • Has a reliable system been established for detecting all the cases (for measuring disease occurrence)?
  • Were the measurement methods similar in the different groups?
  • Were the subjects and/or the outcome assessor blinded to exposure (does this matter)?

Yes, can’t tell  no

5. (a) Have the authors identified all important confounding factors?

  • List the ones you think might be
  • important that the author missed.

Yes, can’t tell  No

(b) Have they taken account of the confounding factors in the design and/or analysis?

HINT: Look for restrictions in design, and techniques, e.g. modelling, stratified-, regression-, or sensitivity analysis, to correct, control or adjust for confounding factors

Yes, can’t tell  no

6. (a) Was the follow-up of subjects complete enough?

Yes, can’t tell  no

(b) Was the follow-up of subjects long enough?

HINT: Consider

  • The good or bad effects should have had long enough to reveal themselves
  • The persons who are lost to follow-up may have different outcomes than those available for assessment
  • In an open or dynamic cohort, was there anything special about the outcome of the people leaving, or the exposure of the people entering the cohort?

Yes, can’t tell  no

(B) What are the results?

7. What are the results of this study?

HINT: Consider

  • What are the bottom-line results?
  • Have they reported the rate or the proportion between the exposed/unexposed, the ratio/the rate difference?
  • How strong is the association between exposure and outcome (RR)?
  • What is the absolute risk reduction (ARR)?

Yes, can’t tell no

8. How precise are the results?

HINT: Look for the range of the confidence intervals, if given.

Yes, can’t tell no

9. Do you believe the results?

HINT: Consider

  • Big effect is hard to ignore!
  • Can it be due to bias, chance or confounding?
  • Are the design and methods of this study sufficiently flawed to make the results unreliable?
  • Bradford Hills criteria (e.g. time sequence, dose-response gradient, biological plausibility, consistency)

Yes, can’t tell no

(C) Will the results help locally?

10. Can the results be applied to the local population?

HINT: Consider whether

  • A cohort study was the appropriate method to answer this question
  • The subjects covered in this study could be sufficiently different from your population to cause concern
  • Your local setting is likely to differ much from that of the study
  • You can quantify the local benefits and harms

Yes, can’t tell no

11. Do the results of this study fit with other available evidence?

Yes, can’t tell no

12. What are the implications of this study for practice?

HINT: Considero

  • One observational study rarely provides sufficiently robust evidence to recommend changes to clinical practice or
  • Within health policy decision-making
  • For certain questions, observational studies provide the only evidence
  • Recommendations from observational studies are always stronger when supported by other evidence

Yes, can’t tell No

Get the Solution to this Assessment

Order Non-Plagiarised Assignment

Get expert assignment help for the Cohort Study Checklist! We specialise in offering high-quality assignment help, with an option for students to pay our experts to take on their assignment challenges. Need a reference? We also provide a free list of assignment examples to help you get started. With years of experience, our writers deliver 100% plagiarism-free content and offer unlimited revisions to meet your needs. Trust us to help you excel in your studies!

Workingment Unique Features

Hire Assignment Helper Today!


Latest Free Samples for University Students

Customer Experience Strategy CW4 Formative Assessment Report Example | BPP

Category: Report Writing Example

Subject: Management

University: BPP Business School

Module Title: Customer Experience Strategy

View Free Samples

BUS7095 Business and Management Research Project Option 4 (Business Plan) Assignment Sample 2024-25, Sem3 | BCU

Category: Assignment

Subject: Business

University: Birmingham City University

Module Title: BUS7095 Business and Management Research Project Option 4 (Business Plan)

View Free Samples

RBP020L063H Leadership and Change Management Assignment Sample

Category: Assignment

Subject: Management

University: University of Roehampton

Module Title: RBP020L063H Leadership and Change Management

View Free Samples

HRMM080 Ethical and Responsible Leadership AS2 Reflective Portfolio Sample

Category: Assignment

Subject: Management

University: University of Northampton

Module Title: HRMM080 Ethical and Responsible Leadership

View Free Samples

ACAD1346 The child’s live Experience Developing Confidence Learners Assignment Sample

Category: Assignment

Subject: Education

University: University of Greenwich (UOG)

Module Title: ACAD1346 The child’s live Experience Developing Confidence Learners

View Free Samples
Online Assignment Help in UK